Council to Finally Debate i360 Loan Report Next Week
Brighton and Hove councillors will scrutinise a long-delayed independent report into the council's £46.5 million loan to the i360 observation tower.
Report delayed since April
The long-awaited independent report into Brighton and Hove City Council's loan to the i360 observation tower will finally go before councillors next week after months of delays.
The Chartered Institute of Public Finance and Accountancy (CIPFA) report was originally scheduled to be debated in April but was withdrawn. Green councillor Pete West, who chairs the committee, said at the time he felt the report was incomplete because it had not contacted those involved in the original 2014 decision to approve a £36 million loan to Marks Barfield, the i360 developer.
Labour councillor Josh Guilmant described the delay as "shameful" at a June meeting. The report is now due to be discussed at Hove Town Hall at 4pm on 24 November, with the meeting to be webcast.
Projections fell short of reality
The CIPFA report found that the council was sold "over-ambitious" business projections. The original business plan predicted annual visitor numbers of between 700,000 and 800,000, but the i360 has attracted an average of around 270,000 visitors per year.
The report noted that the business plan compared the i360 to global attractions including the London Eye, Eiffel Tower and Empire State Building, rather than similar regional attractions such as the Spinnaker Tower in Portsmouth or Blackpool Tower.
Financial projections were also overstated, with the plan forecasting £11.7 million in revenue and £6.7 million in earnings before interest, taxes and depreciation. The actual business struggled to break even and eventually defaulted on its loans.
Council still repaying debt
Brighton and Hove City Council approved the loan when the government was encouraging councils to "think commercially" and borrow at low interest rates. The council is still repaying the loan to the government at £2.2 million per year until 2041 and owes approximately £30 million.
When the i360 company entered administration in December 2024, it owed the council £51 million, including almost £19 million in interest and other debts, plus a further £32 million that the council owed to the Public Works Loan Board.
The report recommended that future projects should include adjustments for optimism bias, modelling of best-case and worst-case scenarios, multiple sources for validating demand, and analysis of market appetite using data and social media.
Source: read the full story

